Two million barrels of Canadian heavy oil is headed to India this month to buyer Reliance Industries, owner of the world’s largest oil refinery.  

India is eager to receive more oil (and natural gas) from Canada for decades to come, according to foreign policy expert Shuvaloy Majumdar. 

“Indian energy demand is essentially bottomless for the long term, and they’re going to need as many sources of energy as possible,” says Majumdar, who recently stepped down as head of the foreign policy and national security program with the Macdonald-Laurier Institute.  

“In the Indo-Pacific region, I’m aware that the Indians are certainly interested in long-term, stable partnerships with Canadian energy because they’re not entirely content with the partnerships that they presently hold.” 

Climbing the ladder of prosperity 

India is expected to have the world’s largest population by 2028, reaching 1.45 billion and rising to 1.67 billion people by 2040, according to the United Nations Population Fund.  

The country is growing fast, but is “yet to climb the ladder of prosperity,” says India’s Ministry of Finance. 

In 2021, India ranked 101 of 167 countries in the Legatum Prosperity Index. The index, published by the UK-based Legatum Institute, considers metrics like safety, personal freedom, living conditions, health, and economic quality. Since 2011, India has moved up the rankings by 11 places. 

It’s likely to keep moving up the list as its economy grows. India’s GDP is expected to more than double over the next decade, reaching $7.5 trillion in 2031 compared to $3.5 trillion in 2022, according to a forecast by Morgan Stanley. 

India is “poised to become the factory to the world,” analysts wrote.  

Rising energy demand 

All of that will take a lot of energy. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), by 2040 India’s total energy demand will be 70 per cent higher than it was in 2019.  

Renewables like wind and solar are expected to grow to supply 10 per cent of India’s energy mix in 2040, up from one per cent in 2019. Meanwhile, oil and gas is projected to rise to 37 per cent in 2040, compared to 32 per cent in 2019, as more natural gas enters the market.  

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s goal is to increase the share of natural gas to 15 per cent by 2030, up from 6 per cent in 2019.  

Mainly through liquefied natural gas (LNG) imports, this will help reduce reliance on coal power.  

Coal supplied 44 per cent of India’s energy needs in 2019, according to the IEA. By 2040, it is still expected to fill 34 per cent of demand.  

India had 23 new coal plants under construction and 21 in pre-construction as of July 2022, according to Global Energy Monitor.  

Reducing emissions 

India has committed to reach net zero emissions by 2070 and is making strides to get there. It has already achieved the target of having 40 per cent of its installed electric capacity come from non-fossil fuels before 2030, the government reports.  

India also co-chairs the International Solar Alliance, which aims to unlock US$1 trillion of investments in solar energy by 2030. 

But India isn’t shy about its ongoing need for fossil fuels. In its latest economic survey, India’s Ministry of Finance highlighted that even in Europe, energy security is again the top priority as nations work to reduce reliance on Russia.  

“When one considers that developed countries set aside their obsessive concerns about climate change and global warming to burn more coal to generate electricity this year… it does not seem so strange or irresponsible that developing countries must put their own growth and development aspirations ahead of their global climate obligations,” the ministry said.  

Canada’s energy opportunity in India isn’t just about oil and gas, Majumdar says – it’s also about critical minerals to meet Indian electrification demand, conventional nuclear technology, small modular reactors, uranium resources, and more.  

“This is not just traditional energy,” he says. “We’re talking emission free nuclear energy, we’re talking about leading edge technologies like hydrogen, carbon capture and sequestration, geothermal; all of these are Canada’s energy proposition.” 

Supply from ‘risky geographies’ 

Canada’s oil and gas industry can be “a form of insurance” against price spikes from unstable suppliers, according to a 2020 report by Gateway House Indian Council on Global Relations. 

“India’s energy trade and investments are concentrated in risky geographies,” wrote author Amit Bhandari. 

India relies on imports for about 85 per cent of its oil and 50 per cent of its natural gas. 

In 2021, its biggest suppliers were Iraq, Qatar and Saudi Arabia, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration. Last year Russia rose to the top, providing as much as 25 per cent of India’s oil imports, according to S&P Global.   

Because of its reliance on imports, India is vulnerable to energy price spikes from geopolitical developments like war, civil strife and government sanctions, Bhandari wrote.   

“If they have a price spikes, they have riots on the streets because they have people who are very vulnerable based on their low incomes,” Majumdar says.  

How Canada can help 

Canadian oil is already being purchased by Indian refiners like Reliance Industries. LNG could do the same, once Canada’s first export project is up and running in 2025.  

Bhandari noted that state-owned Indian Oil Corporation had a 10 per cent stake in the proposed Pacific NorthWest LNG terminal in B.C. before that project was shelved in 2017.  

Using natural gas instead of coal for power generation reduces emissions by about 50 per cent, according to the IEA. A 2020 study focusing on Asia found that LNG from Canada could do even better, decreasing emissions by up to 62 per cent.   

Bhandari says it’s a good idea for India to invest in Canadian oil and gas no matter whether India itself ultimately uses the resources. 

“One of the few ways to protect against high oil prices is by acquiring stakes in oil and gas fields globally — without the oil (or gas) necessarily having to reach India physically,” he wrote.  

“For India, investing in the Canadian upstream should be seen as a form of insurance.” 

The country is a willing customer for Canadian energy, Majumdar says.  

“India is ready to be an investor in our oil and gas. It’s ready to be a purchaser of our oil and gas. It’s ready to be a long-term partner for both our countries’ economic development,” he says. 

“If Canada decided to focus on Indian development, its energy, its education systems, infrastructure, its investment climate, it would put Canada at the heart of Indo-Pacific growth for the next half century.” 

The unaltered reproduction of this content is free of charge with attribution to Canadian Energy Centre Ltd. 

When the International Energy Agency (IEA) called for an immediate halt to all new oil and gas investment worldwide back in May, it appears they neglected to account for two important realities: Africa and Asia.  

Those two continents have been in a population and economic boom for decades. The forecast is for more of the same in the future, to at least 2050. This is relevant given that the IEA and others would like to see oil and natural gas exploration, extraction and consumption stopped dead around the world sooner rather than later.  

A problem for the IEA and others who engage in what amounts to magical thinking: African and Asian demand for oil and natural gas soared in the last three decades. Absent a miracle transformation of technology—which the world’s leading expert on energy transitions does not see—consumers, businesses, and governments in those two continents and everywhere else will need oil and gas as far as the demographic and economic “eye” can see.  

To grasp Africa and Asia’s appetite for energy, consider both continents’ massive population and economic growth.  

Back in 1990, Africa’s population was 630 million people. That doubled to 1.3 billion by 2019 and is forecast to double again to 2.6 billion by 2050. In Asia, the population grew from 3.2 billion in 1990 to 4.6 billion by 2019, and the forecast is for another 950 million people in Asia by 2050. Or put another way, compared with 2019, Africa and Asia will add nearly 2.3 billion people to the planet by 2050.  

As for economic growth, between 1990 and 2019 the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of the emerging economies in Africa and Asia combined has been, on average, above four percent annually. The ten largest African economies increased their collective GDP from $346 billion in 1990 to $1.8 trillion in 2019. In Asia, the GDP of the top ten economies rose from $4.6 trillion in 1990 to $27.8 trillion in 2019. 

That economic growth required energy. Between 1990 and 2018 (the most recent year available for this next statistic), the total annual consumption of oil and natural gas rose by 177 percent. In Asia, the annual consumption of oil and gas between 1990 and 2018 rose by 189 percent. 

Akin to what stock market watchers offer as a caveat, past performance is no guarantee of future returns. It is possible all the forecasts for African and Asian population and economic growth turn out to be wrong, that both continents suddenly cease growing, though we are aware of no such predictions.  

If Africa and Asia do zoom ahead, then consumers, businesses and governments will need much more oil and natural gas.  

That this is likely—renewables will not yet meet the energy need be it in India, Nigeria, or China and South Korea, among others—comes from the world’s leading expert on energy transitions, Vaclav Smil, professor emeritus of the environment at the University of Manitoba.    

Also relevant is if other energy sources can replace oil and natural gas. As Smil noted in a 2018 interview, “In the past, humanity has typically adopted energy sources that have greater ‘power density,’ packing more punch per gram and requiring less land to produce.”  

As Smil also noted, ignoring energy density by moving to all-renewable sources of energy could require countries to “devote 100 or even 1,000 times more land area to energy production than today… [which] could have enormous negative impacts on agriculture, biodiversity, and environmental quality.”  

Given Smil’s caution, a reasonable question to ask is: How likely is it that the public and policymakers in Africa and Asia will cease oil and natural gas usage or halt it at current demand? This is especially relevant given that as even the IEA admits, worldwide, 700 million people do not have access to electricity and 2.6 billion people do not have access to energy to cook a meal.  

In short, it should not be assumed that the population and economic growth already observed in Africa and Asia can somehow be magically delinked from oil and natural gas. The growing economies of Africa and Asia will be hard-pressed to find energy sources as efficient for their needs as oil and gas. 

Mark Milke and Ven Venkatachalam are with the Canadian Energy Centre, an Alberta government corporation funded in part by carbon taxes. They are authors of the report Supersized: Demand for Oil and Gas in Africa and Asia. 

The unaltered reproduction of this content is free of charge with attribution to Canadian Energy Centre Ltd.